How to Write a Good Review for a Teacher Sample

Download Article

Download Article

An article review is both a summary and an evaluation of another writer'south commodity. Teachers often assign article reviews to introduce students to the work of experts in the field. Experts also are ofttimes asked to review the work of other professionals. Understanding the main points and arguments of the commodity is essential for an accurate summation. Logical evaluation of the article'due south main theme, supporting arguments, and implications for further inquiry is an important element of a review. Here are a few guidelines for writing an article review.

Education specialist Alexander Peterman recommends: "In the case of a review, your objective should exist to reflect on the effectiveness of what has already been written, rather than writing to inform your audience virtually a subject."

1. one

   Understand what an article review is. An commodity review is written for an audience who is knowledgeable in the subject instead of a general audience.^[one] When writing an article review, you will summarize the primary ideas, arguments, positions, and findings, and so critique the commodity's contributions to the field and overall effectiveness.

   • Article reviews present more than just an opinion. You will engage with the text to create a response to the scholarly writer'due south ideas. You will reply to and use ideas, theories, and research from your studies. Your critique of the article volition exist based on proof and your own thoughtful reasoning.
   • An commodity review only responds to the author's research. It typically does not provide whatever new research. However, if you are correcting misleading or otherwise incorrect points, some new data may exist presented.
   • An article review both summarizes and evaluates the article.

2. 2

   Think about the organization of the review article. Earlier you fifty-fifty begin reading the article y'all will review, you lot need to empathize how your article review will exist prepare upwardly. This will assistance you understand how to read the commodity so that y'all can write an effective review. Your review will be set in the following parts:

   • Summarize the commodity. Focus on the important points, claims, and data.
   • Discuss the positive aspects of the article. Think about what the author does well, good points she makes, and insightful observations.
   • Place contradictions, gaps, and inconsistencies in the text. Determine if there is enough data or inquiry included to support the writer's claims. Notice any unanswered questions left in the article.

   Advertisement

3. iii

   Preview the article. Begin by looking at the title, abstruse, introduction, headings, opening sentences of each paragraph, and the conclusion. Then read the kickoff few paragraphs, followed by the decision.^[two] These steps should help you start to place the author's arguments and main points. Then read the article in its entirety. When you read the get-go fourth dimension, just read for the large motion picture – that is, look for the overall statement and point the commodity is making.

   • Make note of words or issues y'all don't understand and questions yous have.
   • Look upwards terms or concepts you are unfamiliar with, so you lot can fully understand the article. Read nigh concepts in-depth to make sure you sympathise their full context.

4. iv

   Read the article closely. Read the article a second and third time. Utilise a highlighter or pen to brand notes or highlight important sections.^[3] Highlight the primary points and the supporting facts.^[4]

   Don't: highlight every paragraph — just the cardinal points.
   Practice: supplement the most significant points with notes or cantankerous-references.

   • Connect what y'all read in the article to your existing knowledge of the topic. Remember nearly things y'all have discussed in class or other manufactures you lot accept read. Does the article agree or disagree with your previous knowledge? Does it build on other knowledge from the field? Determine how the article you are reviewing is similar and different from other texts you've read on the bailiwick.^[v]
   • Pay careful attending to the significant of the commodity. Make certain you fully empathise the article. The only way to write a good article review is to empathise the article.

5. 5

   Put the commodity into your words. Y'all can practice this as a free written paragraph or equally an outline. Start past putting the article in your own words. Focus on the argument, research, and claims the article makes. What is the main point driving at?^[6]

   Don't: spend time on editing or phrasing. This is but for your do good.
   Do: write in a articulate, logical construction to test your understanding.

   • With either method, make an outline of the main points made in the commodity and the supporting research or arguments. It is strictly a restatement of the chief points of the article and does not include your opinions.
   • After putting the article in your own words, decide which parts of the article you want to hash out in your review. Yous tin focus on the theoretical approach, the content, the presentation or interpretation of evidence, or the style. Y'all will always talk over the main problems of the article, merely you tin sometimes also focus on sure aspects. This comes in handy if you want to focus the review towards the content of a course.^[7]
   • Review the summary outline to eliminate unnecessary items. Erase or cross out the less important arguments or supplemental data. Your revised summary can serve as the footing for the summary yous provide at the showtime of your review.

6. vi

   Write an outline of your evaluation. Review each detail in the article summary to determine whether the writer was accurate and clear. Write down all instances of effective writing, new contributions to the field, every bit well as areas of the article that need improvement. Create a list of strengths and weaknesses. The strength of the commodity may exist that it presents a articulate summation of a particular issue. Its weakness may be that it does not offer any new information or solutions. Use specific examples and references. For example, the article might have incorrectly reported the facts of a popular report. Jot down this observation in your outline and look up the facts of the study to confirm your observation. Think nearly the post-obit questions to help you critique and engage with the article:

   • What does the article set out to do?
   • What is the theoretical framework or assumptions?
   • Are the primal concepts clearly defined?
   • How adequate is the evidence?
   • How does the commodity fit into the literature and field?
   • Does it advance the cognition of the subject?
   • How clear is the author's writing?^[8]

     Don't: include superficial opinions or your personal reaction.
     Do: pay attending to your biases, and so yous can overcome them.

   Advertisement

1. i

   Come with a title. This title should reflect the focus of your review. Decide between a declarative title, descriptive championship, or interrogative title.^[nine]

2. 2

   Cite the article. Under the title, identify a consummate citation of the article in the proper style.^[10] Go to the adjacent line to begin your essay. Don't skip a line between the citation and kickoff sentence.

   • For example, in MLA, a commendation may look like: Duvall, John North. "The (Super)Market place of Images: Television as Unmediated Mediation in DeLillo's White Noise." Arizona Quarterly l.three (1994): 127-53. Impress.

3. three

   Identify the article. Start your review by referring to the title and author of the article, the title of the periodical, and the year of publication in the first paragraph.

   • For case: The article, "Safe use will increase the spread of AIDS," was written by Anthony Zimmerman, a Cosmic priest.

4. 4

   Write the introduction. The introduction of the article review volition have the identification sentence. Information technology will also mention the central themes of the commodity and the arguments and claims of the writer. You besides need to state the writer'south thesis. Sometimes, the thesis has multiple points. The thesis may non be conspicuously stated in the article, and then you may have to decide the thesis yourself.^[xi]

   Don't: brand statements in the first person ("I").
   Practise: give an overall impression of the article using the third person and a formal, academic manner.

   • Your introduction should only be ten-25% of your review.^[12]
   • End the introduction with your thesis. Your thesis should accost the above issues. For case: Although the author has some good points, his commodity is biased and contains some misinterpretation of data from others' assay of the effectiveness of the rubber.^[thirteen]

5. 5

   Summarize the article. Express the chief points, arguments, and findings of the commodity in your ain words, referring to your summary for assist. Show how the commodity supports its claims. Brand certain to include the article's conclusions. This may exist done in several paragraphs, although the length will depend on requirements established by your instructor or publisher.

   Don't: cover specific examples, statistics, or background information familiar to experts in the field.
   Exercise: capture the chief points of each section, every bit space allows.

   • Use directly quotes from the author sparingly.
   • Review the summary y'all have written. Read over your summary many times to ensure that your words are an authentic clarification of the author's article.

6. 6

   Write your critique. Use your outline of opinions to write many paragraphs explaining how well the writer addressed the topic. Express your opinion about whether the article was a clear, thorough, and useful caption of the subject. This is the core of your article review. Evaluate the article's contribution to the field and the importance to the field.^[xiv] Evaluate the main points and arguments in the article. Decide if the author's points help her argument. Identify whatever biases. Make up one's mind if y'all agree with the writer, then provide sufficient support as to why or why not. Stop by suggesting which audiences would benefit from reading the article.

   Don't: fill your review with a long list of unrelated critiques.
   Do: tie your grievances and praise together into a coherent argument, forming your ain thesis.

   • Back up your critique with evidence from the commodity or other texts.
   • The summary portion is very important for your critique. You must make the author'south statement articulate in the summary section for your evaluation to make sense.^[15]
   • Call up, this is non where you say if yous liked the article or non. You are assessing the significance and relevance of the commodity.^[16]
   • Use a topic judgement and supportive arguments for each opinion. For case, you lot might address a particular force in the first sentence of the stance section, followed by several sentences elaborating on the significance of the point.

7. 7

   Conclude the article review. In a paragraph, summarize the principal points of the article, as well as your opinions about its significance, accuracy, and clarity. If relevant, besides annotate on implications for farther research or discussion in the field.

   • This should only be most 10% of your overall essay.
   • For example: This critical review has evaluated the commodity "Condom use will increment the spread of AIDS" by Anthony Zimmerman. The arguments in the article testify the presence of bias, prejudice, argumentative writing without supporting details, and misinformation. These points weaken the author's arguments and reduce his credibility.^[17]

8. 8

   Proofread. Reread the review. Expect for grammer, mechanics, and usage mistakes. Make certain to cut any extra, unneeded information.

   • Make sure you accept identified and discussed the 3-4 key issues in the article.^[18]

   Advertisement

Sample Commodity Reviews

Add New Question

• Question

  How practise you write an commodity review?

  

  Jake Adams
  Bookish Tutor & Test Prep Specialist

  Jake Adams is an academic tutor and the owner of Simplifi EDU, a Santa Monica, California based online tutoring business offer learning resources and online tutors for academic subjects K-College, Sabbatum & Human action prep, and college admissions applications. With over 14 years of professional tutoring experience, Jake is dedicated to providing his clients the very all-time online tutoring feel and access to a network of excellent undergraduate and graduate-level tutors from top colleges all over the nation. Jake holds a BS in International Business organisation and Marketing from Pepperdine University.

  

  Academic Tutor & Exam Prep Specialist

  Expert Answer

  Skillful article reviews happen when you understand the writer, their perspective, their expertise (or lack thereof), institutional bias that may exist within the paper, and key findings in the article and how they marshal with other conversations beingness had about the article topic. You can write a quality article review like this past paying attention to these questions from the outset and taking notes as yous read the article.

• Question

  How exercise I nowadays figures and tables in a review?

  

  Alexander Peterman is a Private Tutor in Florida. He received his MA in Education from the University of Florida in 2017.

  

  Test Prep Tutor

  Proficient Answer

  Typically, yous won't want to include tables or figures in your review, because this would usually indicate added information from your perspective. All the same, you tin can reference tables and figures in the original piece of work, such every bit by saying, "In Figure 2.one, [writer] demonstrates..."

• Question

  How many articles am I required to written report before writing a review commodity?

  

  Information technology would depend on the discipline of the review article. If the article you're writing requires a lot of knowledge about exterior articles, and so you volition demand to read as many equally possible, though at that place is no required minimum.

• Question

  How practise I create my article title?

  

  The article title should be a succinct, ideally clever description of the general content. In this example, if you were writing a flick review for, say, a bad movie about a ship, you could say something similar, "New Release Sinks at the Box Office."

• Question

  Can yous review more than one article in one written report?

  

  Yes. However, it'due south of import that the articles y'all are going to apply are connected to your study.

• Question

  How do I write a review of a poem?

  

  I would showtime by reviewing the verse form's structure and how effective information technology is. This would include looking at some of the tools that the verse form uses -- ingemination, rhyming scheme, metaphor, etc. -- and deciding whether or not they helped to convey the message of the poet. I would also await at the message of the poem itself and see if it came across clearly and meaningfully.

• Question

  Am I supposed to write the review in paragraphs or with points and headings?

  

  You should write your review in paragraphs.

• Question

  Practice I use references for each and every judgement when writing an article review?

  

  No, you don't have to write references in each and every sentence. Your review should mostly be composed of your own summary and arguments.

• Question

  How exercise I introduce other references in the body if I have consulted others?

  

  At that place are two ways. The first is by using brackets at the stop of a sentence: for exmample, Evidence shows that strategic frameworks are a necessity in successful business management (Smith & Gerald 1998). Or, you can add it in the sentence itself, for example: According to Smith & Gerald 1998 information technology was evident that...

• Question

  Should I use double spacing in this type of write upwards?

  

  It depends on what your teacher wants. Sometimes it may be single spaced, and other times the teacher may want you to double space your work. Bank check with them if yous need description.

Show more answers

Ask a Question

200 characters left

Include your e-mail accost to get a bulletin when this question is answered.

Submit

Advertisement

About This Commodity

Article Summary 10

If you accept to write an article review, read through the original article closely, taking notes and highlighting important sections as you read. Next, rewrite the article in your own words, either in a long paragraph or as an outline. Open your article review past citing the article, then write an introduction which states the article's thesis. Next, summarize the commodity, followed by your opinion about whether the commodity was articulate, thorough, and useful. Finish with a paragraph that summarizes the principal points of the article and your opinions. To learn more about what to include in your personal critique of the article, keep reading the commodity!

Did this summary help you?

Thank you to all authors for creating a page that has been read 2,751,362 times.

Did this commodity help y'all?

quealeyoulike.blogspot.com

Source: https://www.wikihow.com/Write-an-Article-Review

Share :